Total intake wins
Hitting 1.6 to 2.2 g of protein per kg of bodyweight across the day matters far more than whether it lands pre or post. Nail the daily number first, then worry about timing.
Both matter less than your total daily protein and calories; eat protein and carbs within a few hours either side.
The anabolic window is much wider than people think, so exact timing barely matters if your daily protein and calories are on point. Eat a meal with 30 to 50 g protein and some carbs in the few hours before you train for energy, and another in the few hours after. If you train fasted and feel weak, a pre-workout meal will help more than a post one.
Hitting 1.6 to 2.2 g of protein per kg of bodyweight across the day matters far more than whether it lands pre or post. Nail the daily number first, then worry about timing.
A meal 1 to 3 hours before with protein and carbs gives you energy and reps in the tank. If you train early and cannot stomach food, a small snack or a shake works.
You do not need to slam a shake in 30 minutes. As long as you eat protein within a few hours on either side, muscle protein synthesis is covered. Consistency across the day beats any single meal.
Both matter less than your total daily protein and calories; eat protein and carbs within a few hours either side.